Big Daddy’s Pizza

Today I tried the Big Daddy’s medium pepperoni pizza. It’s pretty cheap, but pretty good! Their crust is always my favorite part of their pizzas. For the price, it’s a really good crust. They also typically add a lot of cheese, which is always nice. This one was just about perfect! At least as close as you can get to perfection for about $4.

Marco’s Pizza

This one’s interesting. The pizza’s not bad, but nothing special. I got the All Meat pizza that includes pepperoni, ham, Italian sausage, and bacon. The toppings are good quality, but the crust leaves a lot to be desired. I feel like a slightly different crust would make this an incredible pizza, but the current one holds it back quite a bit.

Their “cheesybread” though. That stuff’s really good. Kind of like my experience with Two Jack’s recently, I’d get Marco’s again for the cheese bread, not the pizza. Two Jack’s cheese sticks are still by far the best I’ve had, but these are still excellent.

Tenney’s Pizza

I’ve known about Tenney’s Pizza for a while, with a few different people recommending I try it over the last couple years. Today I finally gave in. I was intending to go buy groceries and make a more practical dinner, but the idea of trying a new pizza place sounded too good.

Tenney’s pricing is awesome. Their large (14″) pizza includes up to 12 toppings at no extra charge for only $9. I decided to go with pepperoni, sausage, ham, green peppers, parmesan cheese, and yellow onions. I also got some of the cheese sticks to make sure my order was over the $10 minimum for delivery.

You get what you pay for with pizza like this. It’s not a bad pizza by any means, but it’s certainly not up to the level of quality you’d expect buying from Pizza Hut or Domino’s. Overall though, I’m very satisfied. The pizza arrived only 15 minutes after I placed my order, and the pizza and cheese sticks are both pretty good.

Two Jack’s Pizza – Provo, Utah

I’ve heard lots of good things about Two Jack’s, so it was about time I tried it. I got a 2-topping pizza with pepperoni and sausage/olives, and cheese sticks.

So those cheese sticks. Never has there been a more delicious pile of cheese. They’re perfect. A ton of cheese, and a light garlic accent.

The pizza is excellent too. The crust leaves a bit to be desired, but the toppings are exellent quality. It pales in comparison to the cheese sticks, but it’s still great pizza.

Kroger Double Pepperoni Pizza

Take-and-bake grocery store pizzas can vary quite a bit in quality. This one is actually really good! The crust was fairly decent, and the cheese was good, though I certainly wouldn’t consider this amount of pepperoni to be “double” as it was barely enough to get some on each slice. Overall, not a bad choice at all if you want a cheap, fast pizza.

Pieology Pizzeria

This is another one of those build-your-own pizza places that we’ve gotten a ton of here the last few months. This one is decent, but like most of them, is nothing special. I’d put it about half way between Blaze and MOD.

I got the Butcher’s Choice pizza and added green peppers and red onions. The crust left a lot to be desired, but the toppings were fantastic quality. If you’re in the area, it’s not a bad choice.

MOD Pizza

Yet another new pizza restaurant has opened by my house! This one is a lot like Blaze pizza. It’s basically Subway but for pizza, which is a wonderful thing. You can either build your own pizza with whatever toppings, cheese, and sauce you’d like, or pick from one of their “classics.”

I went with their ‘mad dog’ three-meat pizza. It’s delicious. The crust, sauce, cherse, and toppings are all excellent, and the crust in particular is really good. I highly recommend MOD Pizza if there’s one in your area.

Extra Most Bestest Stuffed Crust – Little Caesar’s

There was a time not that long ago, before Hot-N-Ready, when it seemed Little Caesar’s was destined to fail. After Hot-N-Ready, they just didn’t stop. Some of the time this went really poorly, like with their Pretzel Crust, but other times it was incredible, like the Bacon Wrapped Deep Dish (which was probably the best pizza I’ve ever had). This one though… it’s just about perfect. The Extra Most Bestest is already such a great pizza for such a great price that it’s hard to improve on, but adding a bit more cheese in the crust makes all the difference. The price goes up from $6 to $9, but that’s still a great price compared to the competing stuffed crust pizzas.

Papa John’s Pan Crust Pepperoni

I got an ad for a local pizza restaurant that looked a bit disappointing, but it made me hungry for pizza (though what doesn’t), so I decided to try something new from Papa John’s. I’ve never been a huge fan of their pizza, though I don’t really have any complaints about it either. It’s nothing amazing, but it’s pretty good in general. This pan crust pizza is no different. It’s good, simple, quality pizza, but nothing really stands out about it. The cheese sticks are good though.